Discovering your new favorite eyeshadow isn’t difficult, but what if you have four shades to choose from? As we discovered in our “Vibrant Eyeshadow” post, using your natural eye color as a guide is key to uncovering your own runway-ready look. Ladies seeking to make their eyes pop for day or night merely require an eyeshadow palette that features the best shades just for them. Here’s our tips on which hues best suit fashionistas with green, blue, brown, or hazel peepers. Don’t be afraid to experiment until you find the best tones that suit your overall style.

Green Eyes: For daytime, choose a warm chestnut or sandy shade to enhance the natural gold flecks of your eyes, all with minimal makeup. At night, light up any room with glimmering hunter, shimmery jade, or a smoky charcoal.

Blue Eyes: Play up your blues with a soft mauve, which brings out the natural color of your eyes. For evening, add flair to your wardrobe with an eyeshadow in rich sapphire or steel gray.

Brown Eyes: Make chocolate browns shine with a shadow that features gold, especially in soft mauve or creamy pink. For a girl’s night out, be the opposite of a shrinking violet by opting for a plum hue, a la singer Beyonce. Just a hint of grape shadow can easily make brown eyes appear more seductive.

Hazel Eyes: Lucky gals with sparkling hazel eyes can get away with copper eyeshadow to show off their natural sheen. However, to make an unforgettable first impression at night, choose dark bronze, metallic, or even emerald.